July 21 2025 20:20

Martin Slabbert, CEO of Prime Kapital
Prime Kapital Investments (PKI) said on Monday that MAS Real Estate should reject an unsolicited proposal from Hyprop Investments.
Hyprop, which owns malls in South Africa including Rosebank Mall, Hyde Park Corner, Canal Walk and which also has exposure to eastern Europe, made an unsolicited bid for MAS last Friday. Both Hyprop and MAS are listed on the JSE.
“MAS shareholders are strongly urged to exercise caution and reject the recent unsolicited offer made by
Hyprop Investments Limited (Hyprop). The purported offer is not only economically unattractive but also raises significant governance and regulatory red flags,” it said.
“PK Investments, the largest shareholder in MAS, has highlighted that the Hyprop offer is inconsistent with the JSE Listings Requirements governing corporate actions, specifically the requirement for an offer to remain open for twelve days after becoming unconditional. More importantly, the offer is not a bona fide attempt to acquire MAS shares, but rather a cleverly disguised request for MAS shareholders to grant Hyprop free options to acquire their shares at a future date, and at a price far below market value, intrinsic value, and competing offers,” it said.
PKI said that the option is “free” because Hyprop is not required to pay anything upfront for the right to acquire MAS shares in the future.
PKI said the gave Hyprop the right but not the obligation to acquire MAS shares from independent shareholders at a future date, under terms determined by Hyprop, but that the offer must be accepted by July 25 2025.
PKI said Hyprop could choose to exercise the share buying option only if it were beneficial to them, while shareholders would receive no compensation for granting the right, “and are prevented from considering alternatives”.
“The Hyprop proposal is engineered to prevent shareholders from considering alternative offers, locking them into an arrangement that is materially below current trading levels, MAS’s NAV and PKI’s own offer. This is essentially a free call option to Hyprop, with no fixed timeline for implementation,” said Slabbert.
He said the inherent risk for shareholders if they accept the Hyprop free option is that they will be tied up without any time limitation or alternatives as Hyprop seeks to obtain regulatory, shareholder and other approvals. This carried zero risk for Hyprop with shareholders exposed to significant transaction risk, he said.
Hyprop’s bid is such that MAS’ shareholders have the opportunity to sell their MAS shares in exchange for Hyprop shares and/or for cash, subject to certain conditions. Hyprop’s bid includes a share consideration that would offer MAS shareholders 0.42224 Hyprop shares for every MAS share held, which was based on the closing price on May 23 2025. The deal would be worth around R8bn given that MAS is worth R16bn.
But Slabbert said the cash component was a “smoke and mirrors exercise” which is “designed to distract from the deeply unattractive pricing of the equity swap”.
“The cash portion covers only a fraction of the free options Hyprop is seeking, with the equity swap component valuing MAS at just R18.03 or EUR0.88 per share, far below Friday’s market close, a 22% discount,” said Slabbert.
He said the equity swap price was at a 48% to MAS’s NAV while PKI’s offer of EUR1.40 per share was at a 37% discount. PKI’s equity offer values MAS at EUR1.50 per share, at a 42% discount. “It also provides a guaranteed cash exit at 90% of MAS’ adjusted NAV per share,” says Slabbert.
“The offer forces MAS shareholders to dilute their high-quality CEE real estate exposure in favour of a riskier South African real estate profile, with limited rand hedge (capacity), a convoluted corporate structure and a management team with substantially less experience and focus on CEE assets,” said Slabbert.
Slabbert said PKI’s offer was significantly more attractive for MAS shareholders at circa R28.80 per share versus Hyprop’s R24.00 per share.
He said how Hyprop’s offer was conducted raised profound governance and regulatory concerns.
“The offer is not a genuine acquisition, but an attempt to secure control without paying for it, at a price that deeply undervalues MAS in an attempt to hoodwink minority and vulnerable shareholders. This is not just a corporate power grab. It is a fundamental test of governance, fairness, and transparency in South Africa’s capital markets,” he said.
Wilken and Slabbert are both former MAS CEOs. Hyprop owns East European properties worth R13bn in Croatia, Bulgaria and North Macedonia. Slabbert helped to form New Europe Property Investments (Nepi) which listed on the JSE in 2007. It merged with Rockcastle and came to be the largest retail landlord in eastern Europe.
alistair@propertyflash.co.za
- Alistair Anderson
- Alistair Anderson
- Alistair Anderson
- Alistair Anderson
- Alistair Anderson
- Alistair Anderson
- Alistair Anderson
- Alistair Anderson
- Alistair Anderson
- Alistair Anderson
- Alistair Anderson
- Alistair Anderson
- Alistair Anderson
- Alistair Anderson
- Alistair Anderson
- Alistair Anderson
- Alistair Anderson
- Alistair Anderson
- Alistair Anderson
- Alistair Anderson
- Alistair Anderson
- Alistair Anderson
- Alistair Anderson
- Alistair Anderson
- Alistair Anderson
- Alistair Anderson
- Alistair Anderson
- Alistair Anderson
- Alistair Anderson
- Alistair Anderson
- Alistair Anderson
- Alistair Anderson
- Alistair Anderson
- Alistair Anderson
- Alistair Anderson
- Alistair Anderson
- Alistair Anderson
- Alistair Anderson
- Alistair Anderson
- Alistair Anderson
- Alistair Anderson
- Alistair Anderson
- Alistair Anderson
- Alistair Anderson
- Alistair Anderson
- Alistair Anderson
- Alistair Anderson
- Alistair Anderson
- Alistair Anderson
- Alistair Anderson
- Alistair Anderson
- Alistair Anderson
- Alistair Anderson
- Alistair Anderson
- Alistair Anderson
- Alistair Anderson
- Alistair Anderson
- Alistair Anderson
- Alistair Anderson
- Alistair Anderson
- Alistair Anderson
- Alistair Anderson
- Alistair Anderson
- Alistair Anderson
- Alistair Anderson
- Alistair Anderson
- Alistair Anderson
- Alistair Anderson
- Alistair Anderson
- Alistair Anderson
- Alistair Anderson
- Alistair Anderson
- Alistair Anderson
- Alistair Anderson
- Alistair Anderson
- Alistair Anderson
- Alistair Anderson
- Alistair Anderson
- Alistair Anderson
- Alistair Anderson
- Alistair Anderson
- Alistair Anderson
- Alistair Anderson
- Alistair Anderson
- Alistair Anderson
- Alistair Anderson
- Alistair Anderson
- Alistair Anderson
- Alistair Anderson
- Alistair Anderson
- Alistair Anderson
- Alistair Anderson
- Alistair Anderson
- Alistair Anderson
- Alistair Anderson
- Alistair Anderson
- Alistair Anderson
- Alistair Anderson
- Alistair Anderson
- Alistair Anderson
- Alistair Anderson
- Alistair Anderson
- Alistair Anderson
- Alistair Anderson
- Alistair Anderson
- Alistair Anderson
- Alistair Anderson
- Alistair Anderson
- Alistair Anderson
- Alistair Anderson
- Alistair Anderson
- Alistair Anderson
- Alistair Anderson
- Alistair Anderson
- Alistair Anderson
- Alistair Anderson
- Alistair Anderson
- Alistair Anderson
- Alistair Anderson
- Alistair Anderson
- Alistair Anderson
- Alistair Anderson
- Alistair Anderson
- Alistair Anderson
- Alistair Anderson
- Alistair Anderson
- Alistair Anderson
- Alistair Anderson
- Alistair Anderson
- Alistair Anderson
- Alistair Anderson
- Alistair Anderson
- Alistair Anderson
- Alistair Anderson
- Alistair Anderson
- Alistair Anderson
- Alistair Anderson
- Alistair Anderson
- Alistair Anderson
- Alistair Anderson
- Alistair Anderson
- Alistair Anderson
- Alistair Anderson
- Alistair Anderson
- Alistair Anderson
- Alistair Anderson
- Alistair Anderson
- Alistair Anderson
- Alistair Anderson
- Alistair Anderson
- Alistair Anderson
- Alistair Anderson
- Alistair Anderson
- Alistair Anderson
- Alistair Anderson
- Alistair Anderson
- Alistair Anderson
- Alistair Anderson
- Alistair Anderson
- Alistair Anderson
- Alistair Anderson
- Alistair Anderson
- Alistair Anderson
- Alistair Anderson
- Alistair Anderson
- Alistair Anderson
- Alistair Anderson
- Alistair Anderson
- Alistair Anderson
- Alistair Anderson
- Alistair Anderson
- Alistair Anderson
- Alistair Anderson
- Alistair Anderson
- Alistair Anderson
- Alistair Anderson
- Alistair Anderson
- Alistair Anderson
- Alistair Anderson
- Alistair Anderson
- Alistair Anderson
- Alistair Anderson
- Alistair Anderson
- Alistair Anderson
- Alistair Anderson
- Alistair Anderson
- Alistair Anderson
- Alistair Anderson
- Alistair Anderson
- Alistair Anderson
- Alistair Anderson
- Alistair Anderson
- Alistair Anderson
- Alistair Anderson
- Alistair Anderson
- Alistair Anderson
- Alistair Anderson
- Alistair Anderson
- Alistair Anderson
- Alistair Anderson
- Alistair Anderson
- Alistair Anderson
- Alistair Anderson
- Alistair Anderson
- Alistair Anderson
- Alistair Anderson
- Alistair Anderson
- Alistair Anderson
- Alistair Anderson
- Alistair Anderson
- Alistair Anderson
- Alistair Anderson
- Alistair Anderson
- Alistair Anderson
- Alistair Anderson
- Alistair Anderson
- Alistair Anderson
- Alistair Anderson
- Alistair Anderson
- Alistair Anderson
- Alistair Anderson
- Alistair Anderson
- Alistair Anderson
- Alistair Anderson
- Alistair Anderson
- Alistair Anderson
- Alistair Anderson
- Alistair Anderson
- Alistair Anderson
- Alistair Anderson
- Alistair Anderson
- Alistair Anderson
- Alistair Anderson
- Alistair Anderson
- Alistair Anderson
- Alistair Anderson
- Alistair Anderson
- Alistair Anderson
- Alistair Anderson
- Alistair Anderson
- Alistair Anderson
- Alistair Anderson
- Alistair Anderson
- Alistair Anderson
- Alistair Anderson
- Alistair Anderson
- Alistair Anderson
- Alistair Anderson
- Alistair Anderson
- Alistair Anderson
- Alistair Anderson
- Alistair Anderson
- Alistair Anderson
- Alistair Anderson
- Alistair Anderson
- Alistair Anderson
- Alistair Anderson
- Alistair Anderson
- Alistair Anderson
- Alistair Anderson
- Alistair Anderson
- Alistair Anderson
- Alistair Anderson
- Alistair Anderson
- Alistair Anderson
- Alistair Anderson
- Alistair Anderson
- Alistair Anderson
- Alistair Anderson
- Alistair Anderson
- Alistair Anderson
- Alistair Anderson
- Alistair Anderson
- Alistair Anderson
- Alistair Anderson
- Alistair Anderson
- Alistair Anderson
- Alistair Anderson
- Alistair Anderson
- Alistair Anderson
- Alistair Anderson
- Alistair Anderson
- Alistair Anderson
- Alistair Anderson
- Alistair Anderson
- Alistair Anderson
- Alistair Anderson
- Alistair Anderson
- Alistair Anderson
- Alistair Anderson
- Alistair Anderson
- Alistair Anderson
- Alistair Anderson
- Alistair Anderson
- Alistair Anderson
- Alistair Anderson
- Alistair Anderson
- Alistair Anderson
- Alistair Anderson
- Alistair Anderson
- Alistair Anderson
- Alistair Anderson
- Alistair Anderson
- Alistair Anderson
- Alistair Anderson
- Alistair Anderson
- Alistair Anderson
- Alistair Anderson
- Alistair Anderson
- Alistair Anderson
- Alistair Anderson
- Alistair Anderson
- Alistair Anderson
- Alistair Anderson
- Alistair Anderson
- Alistair Anderson
- Alistair Anderson
- Alistair Anderson
- Alistair Anderson
- Alistair Anderson
- Alistair Anderson
- Alistair Anderson
- Alistair Anderson
- Alistair Anderson
- Alistair Anderson
- Alistair Anderson
- Alistair Anderson
- Alistair Anderson
- Alistair Anderson
- Alistair Anderson
- Alistair Anderson
- Alistair Anderson
- Alistair Anderson
- Alistair Anderson
- Alistair Anderson
- Alistair Anderson
- Alistair Anderson
- Alistair Anderson
- Alistair Anderson
- Alistair Anderson
- Alistair Anderson
- Alistair Anderson
- Alistair Anderson
- Alistair Anderson
- Alistair Anderson
- Alistair Anderson
- Alistair Anderson
- Alistair Anderson
- Alistair Anderson
- Alistair Anderson
- Alistair Anderson
- Alistair Anderson
- Alistair Anderson
- Alistair Anderson
- Alistair Anderson
- Alistair Anderson
- Alistair Anderson
- Alistair Anderson
- Alistair Anderson
- Alistair Anderson
- Alistair Anderson
- Alistair Anderson
- Alistair Anderson
- Alistair Anderson
- Alistair Anderson
- Alistair Anderson
- Alistair Anderson
- Alistair Anderson
- Alistair Anderson
- Alistair Anderson
- Alistair Anderson
- Alistair Anderson
- Alistair Anderson
- Alistair Anderson
- Alistair Anderson
- Alistair Anderson
- Alistair Anderson
- Alistair Anderson
- Alistair Anderson
- Alistair Anderson
- Alistair Anderson
- Alistair Anderson
- Alistair Anderson
- Alistair Anderson
- Alistair Anderson
- Alistair Anderson
- Alistair Anderson
- Alistair Anderson
- Alistair Anderson
- Alistair Anderson
- Alistair Anderson
- Alistair Anderson
- Alistair Anderson
- Alistair Anderson
- Alistair Anderson
- Alistair Anderson
- Alistair Anderson
- Alistair Anderson
- Alistair Anderson
- Alistair Anderson
- Alistair Anderson
- Alistair Anderson
- Alistair Anderson
- Alistair Anderson
- Alistair Anderson
- Alistair Anderson
- Alistair Anderson
- Alistair Anderson
- Alistair Anderson
- Alistair Anderson
- Alistair Anderson
- Alistair Anderson
- Alistair Anderson
- Alistair Anderson
- Alistair Anderson
- Alistair Anderson
- Alistair Anderson
- Alistair Anderson
- Alistair Anderson
- Alistair Anderson
- Alistair Anderson
- Alistair Anderson
- Alistair Anderson
- Alistair Anderson
- Alistair Anderson
- Alistair Anderson
- Alistair Anderson
- Alistair Anderson
- Alistair Anderson
- Alistair Anderson
- Alistair Anderson
- Alistair Anderson
- Alistair Anderson
- Alistair Anderson
- Alistair Anderson
- Alistair Anderson
- Alistair Anderson
- Alistair Anderson
- Alistair Anderson
- Alistair Anderson
- Alistair Anderson
- Alistair Anderson
- Alistair Anderson
- Alistair Anderson