Skip to main content

Property Flash

GET PROPERTY FLASH HEADLINES IN YOUR INBOX

July 23 2025 22:00

Sandton Ctiy

The City of Joburg must conduct a new valuation of Sandton City following the Gauteng High Court in Johannesburg which set aside its determination of the country’s uper-market shopping mall’s more than R10bn market value.

Sandton City, which is co-owned by the Liberty Group and investment company Pareto, has successfully challenged the municipality’s valuation of the “five plots of land of the nearly 137,000-square metre Sandton City, which includes a shopping centre, office blocks and a hotel”.

The owners objected to the valuation by the City of Joburg’s municipal valuer Piet El​off, who dismissed their objection and the Valuation Appeal Board also dismissed the appeal.

But in terms of the Municipal Property Rates Act (MPRA), the board is empowered to hear and decide appeals against the decisions of a municipal valuer concerning objections to matters reflected in, or omitted from the municipality’s valuation roll in the area for which it was established.

Pareto and Liberty approached the high court in Johannesburg to review and set aside the February 2023 decision and have the matter adjudicated upon afresh by a differently constituted board.

In the papers filed in court, the companies said that the board’s determination of the market value of the property was “irrational and consequently of no force and effect and that in making its determination, it ignored the provisions of the MPRA”.

The owners argued that the board, in making its determination, valued the property as a group, placing a single value on the erven (plots of land) which comprised it and not on each of its individual components, which was in contravention of several sections of the MPRA. But this contention was later abandoned.

According to the municipality’s former assistant municipal valuer, HJP Fouche, he determined the market value of the property from an analysis of the income derived from properties comparable to it and then drawing the mean from that analysis.

“We use the provable method or the comparable method, meaning that we look at rentals that have been concluded and thus comparable to this property being valued and we use that market information to determine a rental range which we then apply to the property and obviously, this rental range was documented in the market report for the municipality,” he said to media.

Acting Judge Gerald Farber found that Fouche to arrive at the market value of the property, used information embodied in the unregistered leases, which burdened the property.

“It is clear that the board accepted the evidence of Fouche without any proper analysis thereof …The board has fallen far short of its obligations to determine the matter so as to bring about fair administrative justice,” Farber said.

Farber then upheld Liberty and Pareto’s review and set aside the board’s determination. The matter was remitted for “hearing afresh to a differently constituted valuation appeal board of the City of Johannesburg”.

The costs of the review proceedings would paid by the first, second and third respondents; i.e.: board, municipal valuer Piet Eloff and Fouche, jointly and severally, the one paying the other to be absolved, read the judgment

247@propertyflash.co.za

+ posts